Residents put considerable knowledge, time and effort into East Lammermuir’s 2024 Local Place Plan. Two years later, an early task for the LPP Delivery Officer was to make that work easier to find, understand and build on.
This account shares the learning so far, from bringing information together on the ELCC website to creating maps that can be updated as work progresses.
Making existing information easier to use
There was already a wealth of valuable information available through the ELCC website. However, much of it was spread across PDFs. Understanding a priority, how it connected to other proposals and what had happened since could mean reading several documents.
The starting point was to consolidate that information, building on the 2024 plan and presenting it logically and simply on the website. The original documents remain available, while the webpages give residents a more direct way to explore the four ambitions and their associated work.
The learning is that publishing information is only the beginning. People also need a straightforward way to find, understand and use it. Allowing time to organise existing information is a necessary part of moving a plan into delivery.
Bringing the maps back to life
The original maps recorded communities’ aspirations for their places. As PDFs, however, they were difficult to update as projects progressed, circumstances changed or residents brought forward suggestions.
The challenge was to turn them into working maps while keeping a clear connection to the agreed plan. ArcGIS Survey123 and Felt were explored initially, but their costs for the intended work were beyond the available budget. A different approach was needed.
That search led to OpenStreetMap and uMap. OpenStreetMap provides the background map; uMap provides tools for adding local routes, places, descriptions and proposals, organised into layers that people can switch on and off.
Using a free hosted uMap service offered a practical way to bring the maps onto the ELCC website without taking on a recurring mapping subscription. The appendix below explains the options considered and the questions this raised about long-term affordability and access.
More than copying lines onto a map
Recreating the village maps involved checking routes, locations and numbered references against the original plan. Descriptions needed to make sense without someone having the PDF open alongside them.
This also highlighted where local knowledge is essential. A line on a map can appear precise while leaving questions about its intended route, access or feasibility.
The original LPP priorities remain identifiable. New resident suggestions can be added separately, so people can distinguish agreed priorities from ideas being put forward for discussion. A suggested path does not establish a right of access or mean that a project has been approved.
The learning is that working maps need clear references, understandable descriptions and a way to distinguish proposals from agreed actions. They also need opportunities for residents to help identify gaps and corrections.
A foundation to build on
ELCC now has live Local Place Plan maps that can be updated as work progresses, while retaining a clear connection to the original 2024 plan.
Using uMap with OpenStreetMap has made this possible without requiring a paid mapping licence. It provides an open-source foundation to build on, with the maps accessible through the ELCC website.
Free software does not remove the need for care. Information still needs checking, and account access, backups and handover need to be organised. For now, the achievement is bringing the original maps back into use. Further possibilities can be explored as experience and confidence grow.
Recommendations for other localities
- Plan beyond publication. Include time and resources for updates and communication.
- Make information easy to use. Provide accessible website content alongside formal documents.
- Keep editable maps and original versions. Preserve the agreed plan while allowing progress and suggestions to be recorded separately.
- Explore free, open-source tools early. Consider affordability, community access and maintenance before committing to a platform.
- Arrange community control and handover. Ensure accounts, files and knowledge do not depend on one person.
- Reconnect when time has passed. Check what has changed since the plan was produced rather than assuming every proposal remains unchanged.
A Local Place Plan needs ongoing care to remain useful. Keeping information available and maintainable helps preserve the value of the community effort behind it.
Mapping options considered and lessons learned
This comparison records the initial exploration and its relevance to ELCC’s needs. It is not a technical assessment or a current price comparison. Costs and features depend on the product, account and hosting arrangements.
Survey123 is primarily a tool for collecting information through surveys, while Felt and uMap support creating and sharing maps. They were explored as possible parts of the work, rather than as identical products.
| Option | Potential value | Limitations and outcome |
|---|---|---|
| ArcGIS Survey123 | Structured responses linked to locations; potentially useful for resident surveys and field information. | Costs for the intended use were beyond the available budget. Ongoing licence and access arrangements would need consideration. Explored but not taken forward. |
| Felt | Interactive maps, with potential for sharing and collaborative mapping. | Costs for the intended use were beyond the available budget. Continuing editing access and payment after funding ends needed consideration. Explored but not taken forward. |
| uMap with OpenStreetMap | Local information in layers on interactive maps displayed through the ELCC website. No paid mapping licence required for the approach used. | Requires checking, organised editing access and backups. Hosting arrangements still matter. Used to recreate and develop the LPP maps. |
Questions to ask before choosing a mapping tool
- Can residents view the maps, and who will be able to edit them?
- Who controls the account, and how will access be handed over?
- What are the ongoing costs, including any licences for additional editors?
- Who will pay after initial funding ends?
- What happens to viewing, editing and exporting information if payment stops?
- Can copies be backed up and information moved elsewhere?
- What skills and ongoing support will be needed?
These questions should be asked at the start. A community should inherit maps it can continue to use, alongside the access and resources needed to maintain them.
Stay tuned as we learn together by doing—finding what is realistic, practical and sustainable for our community, beyond any individual role or period of funding.